03-29-2009 08:49 AM
Hey All,
Another lesson learned! Over the last few years, I have begun purchasing warranties on just about everything I was buying at Best Buy. I have purchased thousands of dollars worth of electronics, both large and small. With some of the smaller items, like cordless phones and the like, I would pass on the warranties, but when it came time to but the 50" plasma, or the Yamaha sound system, the JBL speakers and those big ticket items, I did buy the warranty. I figured it had to be worth it on those items that I wouldn't classify as "disposable."
Well, the one items that I misclassified was my Sony digital camera. A $400 camera that took incredible pictures. I did buy the warranty on that item thinking that plenty could happen to it and the warranty would come in handy.
Let me tell you about warranties and what I thought they were. Years ago, I worked for a large local (Maryland) chain electronics store. We sold warranties too. However, our warranties were handled differently: if we couldn't fix the large item, we'd replace it and on smaller items, we'd just do an over the counter exchange or exchange it for a similar model if the original was no longer available. So let's get back to my recent experience.
I dropped my Sony camera on a wooden deck. It bent the casing a bit, which in turn also caused the plastic center seal around the perimeter of the camera to be popped open and in turn caused the pictures to turn out blurry. Not a good sign. I took it back to Best Buy and had it reset to the manufacturer's original spec's and then took it home again but encountered the same blurry pictures. Their quick fix didn't work. I brought it back and they advised me to ship it out to have it repaired. It seemed that the warranty I purchased covered basically everything, even dropping it! So, it gets sent out and is gone for close to a month. Keep in mind, not only have I had blurry pictures for the last few months and special occasions but I now have no camera for the next 30 days. I get the camera back and it looks exactly the same, although it has been "repaired." The case is still bent, the plastic strap that surrounds the seam is still popped up and allowing light in between the seam, and now it's missing one of those tiny screws that keeps the housing together. Oh, and I can't tell what was done since the paperwork doesn't tell me (although the Geeks website tells me that they had to wait a week for parts) and it wonderfully (sarcastic) still takes blurry pictures.
Well, Geeks has already told me that it takes FOUR returns back to service before I can get credit for another camera. Three more times, which means three more months throughout the year with no pictures. In my opinion, this isn't worth the hassle!
So, I will probably go and buy the latest and greatest Sony digital compact camera. The one I have, used to take awesome pictures and I will once again have that opportunity, but not because of the extended warranty and I'm not going to buy it this time.
So, the moral of the story is: Buy the warranty on things that you won't be able to replace because of the expense, but if it's something that you can't be without or something that you can classify as "financially disposable", skip the warranty and go to dinner; the dinner will be a much more memorable experience.
Vito
03-29-2009 01:21 PM
I completely agree with you. If you can afford to replace something, then it may be better just to not get the GSBTP. The only GSBTP I have is on my vacuum, because it was so cheap (the GSBTP, not the vacuum.)
And GS was almost right about the No Lemon policy. For a product to be replaced under the No Lemon policy, it must have three qualifying repairs, and be diagnosed as needing a fourth qualifying repair. It doesn't have to actually be sent out the fourth time.
03-30-2009 09:40 AM
Mobile maybe you can explain this to me, as I am not as familiar with the GSBTP as I once was with the BBY service plans.
For items that offer "accidental damage" if/when this damage occurs is it still handled like a regular repair where the item is sent out and repaired?
If it is ir seems odd because I would think most times repairs made on damaged producs would be more costly, and in general I think if the cost of the repair outweighs the cost of the item, then the item is replaced.
For laptops would they bother replacing the LCD, or would they be more likely to just replace the item.
I suppose it is cae by case, but I think although the accidental damage is a good option, it becomes ess attractive if I do not get a new item and just a repaired damaged one.
03-30-2009 12:01 PM
I believe you have an excellent point. I actually thought about dropping the camera in a bowl of water for my second attempt since I was told that I clearly have accidental damage. Although the camera appears to be "okay" from the outside, it clearly was affected by the drop.
I was under the impression that this message board was also a way to get a response from Best Buy representatives as to our issues. I'll wait and see what happens.
Thanks for your comments,
Vito
03-30-2009 01:54 PM
You are correct about the replacement policy. If the repair is economically unfeasible, a replacement is done instead. However, none of us know what price BB gets parts for. I'm sure the relationships with the suppliers ensure BB is given a healthy discount off the price a normal consumer would pay.
Vito, if you were to do that, your plan would then be void, since the ADH does not cover full submersion in water.
You posted on the weekend, so a community connector was not able to get to you. Now that it is a business day, one should be with you in 3-5 business days.
03-30-2009 03:54 PM
I know it sounds silly, but a lot of people see a product that "looks" beat up and doesn't even consider whether the item works or not.
Outward appearance should not be as important as if the thing does what it is supposed to, I know thats not the case here, but a lot of people just want their stuff to look good and as long as thats the case they deal with it.
Like the 1996 Civics I see that are scratched dinged, and beat up, yet will probably outlast my 2006 car. Or the funny people who throw 3500 dollar rims on a car worth 1500.
03-31-2009 03:52 PM
Hi Vito,
I've asked Allan from my team to look into this and follow up with you. You'll be hearing from him shortly.
Thanks for your continued patience,
04-01-2009 09:33 AM
Hi Vito,
I truly am sorry to hear that the extended service plan you purchased on your Sony camera didn’t live up to your expectations, and being a photographer for many years I can imagine how frustrating this whole experience must have been.
I believe our extended service plans are a good deal especially on anything that sees a lot of use (like a camera). I will agree that if you can’t afford to be without your camera for any extended period of time, and you can afford to purchase a new camera if your camera breaks, then the extended service plans might not be for you.
It sounds like you intend on just purchasing a new camera to replace this one, but since you did pay for the Performance Service Plan (PSP) to provide extended coverage you should at least get what you paid for and have a working camera. I would like to see what I can do to get your camera repaired, and hopefully resolve this for you. I am sending you a private message, and to check your messages you should log into the forum and then click on the letter icon in the upper right-hand corner of the page.
Thanks for posting,
Allan
Community Connector
Best Buy® Corporate
