04-08-2010 09:13 AM
Last week I was taking pictures outside with my digital camera. Some guy riding a skate board ran into me and the camera fell out of my hands. Before I realized what happenned it was run over by a car, needless to say the camera was smashed. I took the camera into the store with my ADH warranty and was initially told that it has to be in one piece to be covered. When I pointed out that it doesn't say that in the warranty they told me I wasn't covered because a car ran over it. That language is also not in the warranty. While at the store I call 888-bestbuy and was told that it was the stores decision. Since then I have sent bestbuy corporate 2 emails, with no response. What should I do next? Lawer is too expensive, should I go to BBB? YouTube? Any and all suggestions are appreciated.
04-08-2010 12:37 PM
Good afternoon MartyZ -
Josh, from our Community Connector team, will be reaching out to you regarding your concern. I appreciate your patience until he is able to contact you.
04-08-2010 12:43 PM
Thats odd.
It is usually ultimately up to GSC to determine if a product is covered, although usually car damage is not covered by the ADH GSBTP since it would usually be deemed neglect.
Hopefully Josh from CC can help you out.
~ Josh
04-08-2010 01:01 PM
I understand the neglegent part. But the camera was run over seconds after it fell, I had no time to pick it up.
04-08-2010 01:59 PM
There is no point buying an accidental damage warranty.............
99% of all accidents are customer neglect if you want to push it.
It looks like according to best buy you should have been watching behind you so you could have moved and let the skater pass.
another satisfied customer
04-08-2010 07:26 PM
Actually, I was told that the fall was covered but the car was not. Basically what they said was that If had jumped in front of the car and grabbed the camera, then I would be covered!!!
04-08-2010 09:33 PM
Actually Rsons, in my year and 8 months working for Geek Squad I have had 1 camera and 2 laptops (out of hundreds) come back as customer neglect. Usually involved a car or the product ending up in 20 different pieces.
~ Josh
04-09-2010 12:10 AM
Josh,
I know I have been pretty negative on this site, but hear me out. I honestly think BB has some integrity issues. I mean in their policies and training. I have been a store manager for several retail companies. I was the GM for Service Merchandise for 8 years and had 125 associates that worked for me. We had an Electronics Department and sold extended warranties and replacement warranties. The replacement warranties were a mail in program. If your bike broke , you mailed a pedal back to them and they sent you a gift card for your purchase price. The associates made money off the plans. So, many times I would catch associates saying, "yea, just bring it back to the store if anything............." or "it covers everything". I put pressure on them to sell plans so they sometimes thought they could stretch the truth. I would address it ASAP and it was not a big problem in my store. It WAS a big problem at Service Merchandise. Some Store Managers did not care.......just make the sale.
I think BB associates are selling plans either not knowing or not caring what they tell the customer. I know from my experience it's probably the "don't care" part. Then to top things off, you got a few posters that want to go through the contract line by line, like the sales associate went over it line by line. Anyway, as for me, you lost a customer, as I will never shop there again.......as long as BEARS continues to price match + 10% BUT, I am glad I found this forum......Entertaining as my sports forum.
04-09-2010 06:30 AM
Josh,
If bestbuy considers me choosing not to endanger my life to sae a $400 camera is neglect then bestbuy management has serious integrity issues. Again, there is nothing in the service plan that states that the product has to be in one piece as a result of an accident. This isn't the first problem I had with bestbuy. I bought a PS3 for $600 when it first came out, with a replacement warranty. It started to overheat and freeze up, buy that time the price was down to $400. The store tried to replace a $600 product with a $400 product, they didn't want to credit me the difference. This was in complete contradiction to the language in the replacement warranty, the replacement warranty clearly states that the store will credit the customer the original purchase price to allow the customer to choose his own replacement.
In my view bestbuy/geek squad associates are trained to say NO in the assumption that most people will accept that answer!!!
04-09-2010 08:17 AM
Marty and Rsons, do you realize how big Best Buy is? They have over 1,000 stores.
1,000 stores...
Every single one of those stores have trained associates who are SUPPOSE to be trained on the Standard Operating Platform.
If the in-store management are being cowboys and training their associates differently, or they are being improperly trained then they need to be reported to Corporate to be rectified.
However, just as with every other company there are bad apples and there are good apples.
You can't just claim that because you had a bad visit that all stores are bad.
Humans are humans, and to err is human.
Marty, I am not going to contradict what you said, because as far as I know we replace the product 100%, usually Customer Service handles that, I only handle the testing to verify it is locking up and not working correctly.
Rsons I will agree that associates sometimes try to seal the deal with "It covers everything and just come into the store", these forums are proof of that statement, however that is not all of Best Buy, although I do agree they need better control over in-store associates and maybe need more walks from district and territory.
However, my ONLY point in making these posts is simply to try to tell people that just because ONE store was bad does not mean all of them are, there are over 1,000 of them after all.
And yes, I come down hard on associates when I hear them selling like that, which luckily happens very little in my store.
And I hate to bring it up, but the consumer DOES need to read the terms of their agreement, Rsons if you sold a repair plan on something, and then they come back claiming the associate told them they could replace it a YEAR later, would you just penny out a new unit even if it costs you thousands to do so? Or do you tell them that they have a copy of their terms and conditions and that sadly enough it was their responsibility to read them prior to or right after accepting it, since it most likely was returnable.
~ Josh
P.S. I want to reiterate to everyone here, I am not trying to flame I am simply trying to have a discussion.
Also Marty, I forgot to address your first line. Sadly enough a lot of people try to scam Best Buy and claim that their camera, or computer, or whatever "broke" and they drive over it with a car, throw it into the mud, slam it against a wall, so obviously these units are handled with care..
I am not saying I agree with this, simply making a mention of how some people are very deceptive and try to get everything they can (NOT SAYING YOU ARE).
